Nantucket, with its cobblestone streets, iconic lighthouses, and scenic beaches, is often seen as a quintessential New England escape. But beneath the surface of its polished seaside image lies a trove of lesser-known experiences, perfect for travelers seeking a more authentic and enriching encounter with the island. Here’s how to discover Nantucket’s hidden treasures, from serene nature spots to local art hubs.

1. Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge: A Nature Lover’s Paradise

For those looking to escape Nantucket’s bustling tourist areas, the Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge offers a peaceful retreat into nature. Located on the northeastern tip of the island, this 1,100-acre refuge is a unique blend of coastal ecosystems—featuring dunes, forests, and salt marshes. The refuge is home to a variety of wildlife, including ospreys and seals, and its remote landscape provides a perfect backdrop for hiking or beachcombing.

One of the highlights is a visit to the Great Point Lighthouse, which can be reached through a scenic drive or bike ride along the narrow barrier beach. The views at the tip of the island, where the lighthouse stands, are simply breathtaking.

For more information and to plan your visit, check out: The Trustees of Reservations.

2. Sconset Bluff Walk: A Hidden Coastal Path

Tucked away in the charming village of Siasconset (“Sconset” to locals) lies one of Nantucket’s best-kept secrets: the Sconset Bluff Walk. This scenic, unmarked path winds along the cliffside, offering panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean on one side and quaint, rose-covered cottages on the other. Unlike the typical coastal trails, this footpath takes you through private backyards, blending the island’s natural beauty with the historic character of the homes.

The Bluff Walk is a peaceful and intimate way to experience Nantucket, far from the crowds of the downtown area. It’s ideal for a leisurely morning stroll or a sunset walk, providing plenty of photo-worthy moments.

Discover more about Sconset and its trails at: Nantucket Conservation Foundation.

3. Nantucket Shipwreck & Lifesaving Museum: Stories of Bravery and Survival

While many visitors flock to Nantucket for its whaling history, the island also has a fascinating maritime rescue legacy. The Nantucket Shipwreck & Lifesaving Museum, located just outside of town, is dedicated to the stories of the brave individuals who rescued sailors from the island’s treacherous shores. This often-overlooked museum offers exhibits on Nantucket’s perilous waters, recounting shipwrecks and heroic rescues that date back centuries.

For history buffs or those with an interest in maritime lore, this museum provides a compelling perspective on the island’s relationship with the sea, often overshadowed by its whaling fame.

For more details, visit: Nantucket Shipwreck & Lifesaving Museum.

4. Cisco Brewers: A Craft Experience in a Secluded Spot

Although Cisco Brewers has become popular with locals and savvy travellers, it still feels like a hidden gem compared to the more tourist-heavy establishments downtown. Located in a tucked-away part of the island, Cisco Brewers is also a winery and distillery, offering a laid-back atmosphere where you can sample craft beers, wines, and spirits all in one place.

Visitors can enjoy live music, food trucks, and a casual picnic area, making it the perfect spot to relax after a day of exploring. The brewery often hosts events and festivals, so it’s worth checking their calendar before your visit.

Plan your trip to Cisco Brewers here: Cisco Brewers.

5. The Artists Association of Nantucket: Discover Local Art

While Nantucket is known for its whaling history, the island is also home to a vibrant arts community. The Artists Association of Nantucket (AAN) is a hub for local artists, offering exhibitions, classes, and events throughout the year. Located in the heart of downtown, the AAN’s Cecelia Joyce & Seward Johnson Gallery showcases works from local painters, sculptors, and mixed-media artists who draw inspiration from the island’s landscape and culture.

Whether you’re an art collector or just appreciate the creativity of local artists, a visit to the gallery offers a fresh perspective on Nantucket’s artistic heritage, away from the commercialized shops of the main street.

Learn more about their programs and exhibitions: Artists Association of Nantucket.

A Deeper Connection with Nantucket

Beyond its picture-perfect beaches and postcard views, Nantucket offers an array of hidden experiences that allow visitors to connect more deeply with the island. From remote nature reserves to intimate art galleries, these lesser-known attractions showcase the island’s rich cultural, historical, and natural beauty—without the crowds. For travellers seeking to go off the beaten path, these spots offer a more authentic, unforgettable taste of Nantucket.